I was a musician. I was never a good one
I've had a lot of hobbies in my life and one of them was playing various instruments. It started out as me just doing some vocals and realizing that I was the only one of my friends that had the pipes to hit Axel Rose's range in some (definitely not all) of their popular songs. Later in life a friend gifted me a guitar and I bought an amp. Even later in life a group of people asked me to join their band because of my look and I did so. That band stayed together for 4 years and we even went on a tour of sorts.
During all of this I was never very good at what I did, but I knew my role and I stuck with it and that made me a useful member of the group. I think this is where a lot of musicians screw up when they try to be the frontman when they don't really have the talent for it.

src
When I became the bass player in this band, I knew very little about playing bass or really about playing any stringed instrument, but I did know where the notes were and I could also follow anyone who used bar chords or power chords without them even telling me the notes. Bass is easier in that regard, especially if you have a good "ear" and you also have rhythm: I have both.
I never got involved in song-writing but I did practice the songs so that I would never make a mistake. I was also perfectly content to remain in the background and not really stand out. I wasn't trying to do backup vocals or be a standout like Flea is with the RHCP. I was a team player and the band worked because of this. When too many people are competing for the spotlight, there is no spotlight anymore.
We had a drummer in that band that was likely the best drummer I have ever seen in my life but because of that talent and his desire to always showcase it, he actually ended up ruining a lot of the songs and making it quite difficult for the rest of us to remain playing a cohesive sounding song. I can keep time (rhythm) in my head without a 1,2,3,4 but he didn't make it easy, that is for sure.
The thing is the crowd, other than other drummers, didn't appreciate this either. It sounded to them like a lot of noise. Think about AC/DC for example... do you really think that the drummer is not capable of more than what he does in those songs? Of course he is... but there is a rule in music called KISS which means, keep it simple, stupid.
I kept it simple out of necessity, I was not capable of doing a bass solo and I never even tried. Even though I played bass I hated Primus, if you know what that is, because it just sounds like noise.
Another bass player that I knew was constantly trying to get in the limelight so he bought a used stand-up bass that is usually used in Rockabilly music. It was beat up, un-amplified, and had no frets. You could barely hear the guy at gigs and when you did hear him, the notes were often wrong. What's the point of all that?
This band in college never really went anywhere but we did play a lot of local gigs and I managed something that isn't often accomplished by bass players in college bands: I got kicked out of the club that we were playing at during a break. A friend of mine offered me some cocaine in the bathroom and we got busted. I don't do stuff like that anymore but I did at the time.
Anyway, when the set break was over I was standing outside and could hear the singer asking "has anyone seen our bass player?" on the microphone. I'm standing outside telling the bouncer that it's me they are looking for. He reluctantly had to let me back in.
Let's move forward a bunch of years after I had already graduated and was living in Thailand.

not gonna show my face, but that sweaty and fat ass belongs to me
I hadn't been in a band in years but one day at a party some karaoke was going on and I did "Have you ever seen the Rain" by CCR on the microphone and some members of an already existing band were in the crowd. They approached me and asked me if I wanted to try out for their band.
As it turned out they needed a bass player as well and I said "well, I do that also.... kind of"
I ended up being in that band for a couple of years and played about 10 gigs in Thailand which were completely illegal. Illegal in the sense that you are not allowed to play for money without a work permit.
We played a lot of gigs because if there is one thing that Thai bands love more than anything else it is to have an all foreigner band open up for them. Our largest gig was in Krabi and we opened up for one of the biggest (at the time) punk-ish bands in the country called "Mummy Daddy." It was a sold out show of around 600 people in attendance and we got the crowd so warmed up that the jerks in Mummy Daddy tried to cut us off before we finished our set. I could see the club manager heading our direction and shouted at the band to ignore him and to quickly play our biggest "hit."
The band was unhappy about that but I wasn't going to leave the stage before playing our biggest "hit." It was a hit in the sense that something like 50 people knew the words to it.
Here's Mummy Daddy if you care... but just like most punk rock bands including my own at the time, they are a lot better live.
Those were absolutely fantastic times but also filled with trials and tribulations especially the time that the police mass raided one of the clubs we were playing at and the French guitar player, who had already been arrested once for playing illegally, fled the stage in the middle of a song and just ran off. The police were not there for us, they didn't even care.
That's where I will stop this story because it is already dangerously long. I will do a part two of this story because it gets even better.
We had the same look strat bass and a matching stratocaster electric guitar, probably the same sweaty phat ass like you 😂 ours is black color though, we ended up selling those equipment for a cheap price after our drummer called it quit as he deserved a better band.
Ever since, I've been on freelance or attending a temp gig instead whenever someone needed a filler to slot in, and I will go for free beer or a 50 RM fee(that's like $10 😂) for a 2 hour gig.
I still maintained a Yamaha ERB-II bass currently, and a series of jazz guitars, full hallow, semi hallow, a flying V, an SG, a kid size classical guitar, and one practice grade classical guitar I am still playing for church every Saturday. Gift away my Baldwin Les Paul to my nephew, a strat to my bro in law, an electric full hallow jazz to another nephew, donated another strat to a charismatic church. Oh I have a broken violin and a broken banjo somewhere around the house. Not sure what to do with them.
Your reply is upvoted by @topcomment; a manual curation service that rewards meaningful and engaging comments.
More Info - Support us! - Reports - Discord Channel
Haha awesome!
Playing in a band is best when it is a hobby you share with friends. Maybe like golf, it is best when you are not great at it and have no delusions of grandeur. I love playing with the guys in the 2-3 shows we do per year and just having fun with it. So good no matter how good your are.
I'm envious, was never in a band but did some jamming just once and loved it.
Mummy daddy pretty darn awesome sounding. Having a bagpipes makes it even more unique yo!
Sounds like some fun times. I've played guitar most of my life, but didn't play much with others until my 40s. Some years on I've played a fair few gigs for fun with various lineups as well as solo open mics. I've even written some songs. It is great if you can find the right people to play with, but I don't think I could have done the whole thing of struggling to make a career from music. I currently have a jazz band where I'm playing drums and we play gigs a few times each year.
I think you get out of music what you put in. I would not have got into these groups if I hadn't started a pub jam session as I just didn't know many musicians before then. I'll keep doing it for fun as long as I can.
I've not had a police raid at a gig yet :)
Rock on!
!BEER
Your reply is upvoted by @topcomment; a manual curation service that rewards meaningful and engaging comments.
More Info - Support us! - Reports - Discord Channel
View or trade
BEER.Hey @gooddream, here is a little bit of
BEERfrom @steevc for you. Enjoy it!We love your support by voting @detlev.witness on HIVE .
View or trade
BEER.Hey @gooddream, here is a little bit of
BEERfrom @steevc for you. Enjoy it!We love your support by voting @detlev.witness on HIVE .
You have definitely lived a busy life and must have some great stories to tell. The drummer sounds like a proper dick trying to be noticed and not playing his role. I don't have great ears so music is music to me and could not distinguish between the different notes properly.
Playing an instrument is sometimes more than a hobby; it's an escape from the stress of everyday life, and if we can make music with other friends, that's something incredible.
I love everything of this story, especially the guitarist running away part 😂
Sounds like a pretty amazing time! I was in band in school playing percussion, but I was never that good. I never learned to read music and I bought a guitar a while ago, but never learned how to play it. I still have it down in the basement. I still hope to learn one day. I know what you mean about the player being secretly talented. If you look at most the Beatles songs, they are pretty simple when it comes to the drumming, but you know Ringo is one of the greatest drummers in the world.
Random but genuinely curious, are you still friends with the guy who gifted you a guitar? I feel like anyone who'd be generous enough to do that must be a pretty decent fella.
Also, how illegal is it exactly in Thailand? Is it like actual jail time you could risk to play music live without a permit, or are we just talking like a small fine and a slap on the wrist type deal?